Round 10/Ideas

Write your initial ruleset ideas for Round 10 here. We can then make a poll in #announcements to pick one of them and write a draft.

Baba is Nomic
Clearly the best idea so far and all other ideas are inferior (objectively). Listed first because you can just read this idea and skip all of the rest, I'm saving you the trouble. You're welcome.

Mao
Discussion so far:
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/515607055223095300/799734127828926557
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/839940555722850314
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/841492476162605096

The Council
A Mafia/Werewolf game where players can propose any change to the rules. There is one Outsider who plays in the team with hidden information and has veto power but may not veto a certain class of proposals.

https://kevan.org/games/thecouncil

Discussion so far:
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/840220616391917588

Bot
A round where there's a Discord bot that holds the game state (as a database / set of files) and the rules (as Python code). And then proposals are Github pull requests and game actions are Discord bot commands. The initial ruleset can be anything (determined via a second round of polling). There's some code https://github.com/Mathnerd314/NomicBot that's somewhere around halfway usable, it would need to be finished.

As envisioned the bot is canonical in the sense that errors in the bot code are not fixable except by convincing the bot to modify itself. We could add a "bot owner" or judge role with the authority to reset the bot if it gets too far off track.

Discussion so far:
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/799337601466105936 (secret role bot, discussion of which language)
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/810614640609984573 (other bot nomics, discussion of databases)
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/515607055223095300/815879147544641546 (whether Infinite Nomic is the place to host a bot nomic)

Auction Poker
The Liar Game round, but for Nomic

Proposals can only be made by using a proposal-making item, and only a limited number of proposal-making items is available in each cycle. However, proposals always pass unless a [very high number or fraction] of players votes against it. To keep the game running despite these limitations, Ruleset and Gamestate adjustments can be made by judges.

At the beginning of a week, each player gets an amount of points and two randomly generated cards. All other cards are then put up for auction (each card being an individual lot) Once the auction phase is over, a bartering phase begins where players can trade points and cards. At the end of the cycle players present their hands and they are ranked from best to worst. Each player gets a prize according to their hand's rank (if they get a prize at all). Prizes could be proposal-making items, proposal veto items, guaranteed cards for the next week, etc.

I think this would work best if we only use high-cards or 2 card suits, otherwise the lots might not face enough competition during the auctions.


 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/786317704386314291

Doomsday Timer
There are two teams and a timer that counts down. One team has to get the timer to zero and the other has to stop it, but the timer can only be manipulated through a certain mechanic. One of the teams could consist of a single player.


 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/786320510152605708
 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/518856008605499402/786322546185732196

re-run a previous round
Take the initial/final ruleset from a previous round and use it as the initial ruleset for this round.


 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/515607055223095300/819243459357179905

Tribute Round
The initial ruleset contains one element from each previous round.


 * https://discord.com/channels/515560801394753537/515607055223095300/819244812330598431

Rounds with different time frames
One idea that i think would be super interesting to try out is either a nomic that is meant to progress extremely quickly or one that lasts only hours.

Long Round
original discussion


 * Plant theme? Players get trees which grow 1 centimeter a week?
 * Can call it Round Infinity or something quirky like that.
 * Definitely intended to run in the background of every other round.

Short Round
original discussion


 * Choose a range of hours between which everyone can participate
 * "10 hour round 10" is thematic but maybe impractical: still want it to be short enough that it can be played in one sitting
 * Mechanical ideas in case this is a hard sell:
 * Definitely want win condition baked into the initial ruleset because we won't have time to create one and work towards it
 * Furthermore, this should be a "most points at the end" condition so that the game can have a specified length
 * Game can work on an hourly clock. i.e. proposals written in hour n are voted on in hour n+1
 * Allow players to pick teams? Having people discuss the ruleset with small groups may lead to better strategizing and more importantly better scamming
 * Release the ruleset and send the call for teams long before the round actually starts so that people have time to make plans